Trump Gaza relocation plans ‘recipe for creating chaos and tension’: Hamas
Trump Gaza relocation plans ‘recipe for creating chaos and tension’: Hamas
Al Jazeera’s senior political analyst, Marwan Bishara, highlights the unified opposition of Arab League nations to the displacement of Palestinians from Gaza. He emphasizes that despite this stance, the Trump administration remains convinced it can pressure countries into agreement. Bishara suggests that Trump’s vision of transforming Gaza…
source
Reviews
0 %
What a embarrassment, our country. Lord stop him.
رَبَّنَا آتِنَا مَا وَعَدتَّنَا عَلَى رُسُلِكَ وَلاَ تُخْزِنَا يَوْمَ الْقِيَامَةِ إِنَّكَ لاَ تُخْلِفُ الْمِيعَادَ
Protecting Innocent Lives: Human Rights and the Gaza Relocation Plan
Forced relocation of Gaza's civilians to neighboring countries is a serious violation of human rights. Innocent people, including children, are being treated as pawns, which goes against international laws like the Geneva Conventions. These conventions clearly state that civilians should never be forcibly displaced.
There are also troubling suspicions that Israeli secret services may have infiltrated and manipulated Hamas to incite violence and hostage-taking. This could then be used as a pretext to displace Gaza's residents. Such actions, if true, would be an orchestrated violation of human rights.
The international community must stand firm against any plans that harm innocent civilians and ensure their protection and dignity. Let's not forget, these are real people with real lives, and their rights should be respected. Gaza's civilians to neighboring countries is a serious violation of human rights. Innocent people, including children, are being treated as pawns, which goes against international laws like the Geneva Conventions. These conventions clearly state that civilians should never be forcibly displaced.
There are also troubling suspicions that Israeli secret services may have infiltrated and manipulated Hamas to incite violence and hostage-taking. This could then be used as a pretext to displace Gaza's residents. Such actions, if true, would be an orchestrated violation of human rights.
The international community must stand firm against any plans that harm innocent civilians and ensure their protection and dignity. Let's not forget, these are real people with real lives, and their rights should be respected.
If Trump’s plan were somehow implemented—which is highly unlikely—the ownership and governance of Gaza would become a major issue. There are a few possible scenarios:
1. Israeli Control (Most Likely Scenario in This Plan)
• If Gaza’s Palestinian population were removed, Israel might take full control of the territory.
• However, Israel has historically been reluctant to directly govern Gaza due to the costs and political risks.
• Israel’s far-right politicians might push for settlements in Gaza, making it effectively annexed.
2. International Administration (Unlikely but Possible)
• The U.S. or a coalition of countries could attempt to establish an international governing body to control Gaza.
• This could involve the United Nations or Arab states managing the region temporarily.
• However, no country or organization is likely to take responsibility for such a controversial move.
3. Egyptian or Jordanian Control (Almost Impossible)
• Some have suggested that Egypt or Jordan could take over Gaza and the West Bank.
• However, both countries have rejected this idea, as it would bring instability and economic strain.
4. A “New” Palestinian State (Highly Unlikely in This Plan)
• Some might argue that Trump’s plan would involve creating a Palestinian state elsewhere, possibly in parts of Egypt’s Sinai desert or Jordan.
• This would be widely rejected by Palestinians, who demand their historical land.
Final Verdict: Chaos, Not a Clear Owner
If Trump’s plan somehow moved forward, Gaza would likely remain in a state of chaos rather than having a clear new owner. Israel might control it by force, but international backlash would be severe. The most realistic outcome would be ongoing instability rather than a stable new governance structure.
It is highly unlikely that Trump’s plan to relocate over 2 million Palestinians from Gaza will succeed. Here’s why:
1. Palestinian Resistance
Gaza’s residents have endured wars, blockades, and severe humanitarian crises without fleeing in large numbers. They see Gaza as their home, and forced displacement would be met with strong resistance. Even in the face of Israel’s ongoing military operations, most Gazans have remained. If they didn’t leave under these extreme conditions, they’re even less likely to leave under Trump’s plan.
2. International Law & Human Rights Issues
Forcibly relocating an entire population is considered a violation of international law and could be classified as ethnic cleansing. The United Nations and human rights organizations would strongly oppose it, making it politically and legally difficult to implement.
3. Regional Opposition
Egypt and Jordan, the two main neighboring countries, have already rejected the idea of accepting mass Palestinian refugees. These countries fear destabilization, economic burdens, and backlash from their own citizens. Without regional support, there’s no feasible way to relocate millions of people.
4. Logistical and Financial Challenges
Moving over 2 million people would require an enormous logistical effort, including housing, food, employment, and infrastructure in new locations. Even if Trump were to fund such a project, which is doubtful, there’s no practical way to resettle such a large population quickly.
5. Israel’s Stance
Even Israel might not fully support this plan. While some hardliners may favor displacement, it would bring immense international pressure on Israel, potentially worsening its diplomatic standing.
6. U.S. Political Limitations
Trump, even if reelected, would face significant opposition from Congress, international allies, and within the U.S. government. Many American politicians, including those who support Israel, would not back a plan that violates international norms and risks further destabilizing the Middle East.
Conclusion
Trump’s proposal is more of a political statement than a realistic policy. The Palestinian people, regional powers, international law, and logistical barriers make it nearly impossible to implement. It’s unlikely to work, and even if attempted, it would lead to massive resistance and global condemnation.
Well spoken. It is a pity there is mad man in the Whitehouse
Boomshakalaka
I am the son of perdition. I am the last who will come after. Mark my words, the world leaders are paving my way. No man will be able to make war against me, for I shall be the king that cannot be Conquered by earthly mortal armies.I will live in the heart of Jerusalem. All will bow before me. Until then I will wait in the shadows of mankind.
I would not worry about Trump owning Gaza he would have it bankrupt less than a year
He wants to remove them from the war torn gaza and give them another piece of land. Mr. Trump said that he wants to develop the new land, build homes for the Palestinians and get them job's. Right now he's going to help the most vulnerable children with emergency care.
Reject every two-state solution. "From the river to the sea" right? You want it all right? Now become a resort for others to enjoy.
Bill Clinton was spot on 25 years ago. These are his words – "I think 25 years from now, they [the Palestinians] won’t be able to say, ‘Oh, we couldn’t have a state because the Israelis wouldn’t let us.’ They’ll have to explain that the reason they don’t have a state is because they didn’t take the deal that was on the table in 2000. It was a good deal. It was the best deal they were ever going to get. It was the best deal they could have gotten at that time, and the Israelis made significant concessions. Arafat could have taken it, but he didn’t. And now, the Palestinians have to live with the consequences of that decision. And that’s a real problem."
This is why a two-state solution is a fool's errand. Only a people who refuse to live next to the Israelis will refuse this deal – A Palestinian state would be established in most of the West Bank and Gaza Strip (about 94-96% of the West Bank and all of Gaza). Israel would withdraw from most settlements, except for major settlement blocs near Jerusalem (which Israel would compensate with land swaps).
So keep on chanting "From the river to the sea". Keep on believing that all of Palestine is rightfully yours. Keep on waging war with Israel. And we'll see where you are 25 years fron now.
If Hamas had any regard for the Palestinians this would not have happened.
Congrats Dearborn!!!
If Palestinians are forced to relocate, then they should receive profits from the oil and natural gas that's off the shore of Gaza.
"A recent study by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) points out that new discoveries of natural gas in the Levant Basin are in the range of 122 trillion cubic feet, while recoverable oil is estimated at 1.7 billion barrels. These reserves offer an opportunity to distribute and share about $524bn among the different parties in the region." (Aljazeera site)
Trump wants valuta back for all the american weapons and money american taxpayers gave Israel to kill innocent civilian kids in gaza
So now he wants to build casinos and hotels in the gaza strip so the rich jews and his buddys can have fun in gaza while his voters are struggeling and still have no free healthcare system, Los Angeles just burned and people are becoming homeless in newyork but instead he wants to build casinos and hotels in the gaza strip thats crazy its like he wants to be worse than biden
Israël owns the economy of USA ROTHCHILD & CO
Why are you insulting people. It reveals who you are, and Aljazeera anchor man allows you to continue with such an un civil language.
crazy world but as long as the even crazier gaza cannot do more terror to israel i suppose.
Israel and America must stop the GENOCIDE of the Palestinian people.
IF TRUMP AND HIS FAMILY , NETAN AND ISRAELI JEWS BECOME MUSLIM , ONLY THEN WE MIGHT GIVE YOU SOME SPACE IN PALESTINE !!!!!!!
offer each Gazans 50 thousand US dollar and 20 thousand Aid to the country they relocate. Total : 140 billion.
Trump needs to be impeached from the white house he is a trouble maker bulley.
Hamas remark is not relevant
Let them try let them TRY. They forget that NOTHING happens without the WILL OF ALMIGHTY ALLAH SWT. NOTHING!!!!.Or perhaps this moron Trump is deliberately stirring the pot for a war.
jews own usa ???
There's $4bn plus in natural gas reserves off the coast. It's part of one of the biggest g as reserves in the area, Israel and the USA want it.
I read something about the natural GAS in Gaza🤨???
😰🙌Marwan,I'm in South Africa 🇿🇦 and we are being bullied by Trump as well😰👺I love you‼️♥️♥️♥️
Marwan living in 5 star luxury in Qatar
Im from South Africa and i cant see this happen imagined vacationing on beach properties that have been built on the lives, blood and bones of the indigenous people who have been systematically killed and now removed to go who knows where.
They did it in iraq afghanistan.
Succeeded in syria working on gaza.
We voted for America 1st not Israel 1st
Palestine would be best to loose the covered mask with a gun look and elect a well spoken, dynamic and likable leader that the rest of the world can support. I am tired of seeing the Hamas stereotype and a old harmless grandpa for a leader in the west bank that does nothing but read from scripts
I'm not Jewish
Clear evidence Trump is a servant of Israel not America.